Hello dear
Welcome to Gaby's Pizza
At Gaby's Pizza, we are passionate about bringing the authentic taste of New York pizza to the heart of Hollis, NY. Established with a commitment to quality, our classic pies are crafted with deliciously balanced dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of perfectly melted cheeses, ensuring every bite is a delightful experience. With options for delivery, takeout, and outdoor seating, we cater to families and pizza lovers alike. The welcoming atmosphere is enhanced by friendly staff and a nod to our history through vintage decor. At Gaby's, we celebrate tradition while creating memories over slices that keep our community coming back for more.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Cheese
Carbonara
Tossed Salad
Caesar
About
Gaby's Pizza
Welcome to Gaby's Pizza, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Hollis, NY, where classic New York-style pizza takes center stage. With its rich history and a commitment to quality, Gaby's has garnered a loyal following among locals and pizza enthusiasts alike.
- Location: 204-23 Hillside Ave, Hollis, NY 11423
- Contact: (718) 740-9716
Gaby's Pizza stands out as a go-to spot for both casual diners and families searching for a welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant offers a range of services including delivery, takeout, catering, and even dog-friendly outdoor seating. With options for reservations and several payment methods available, Gaby’s makes enjoying pizza a breeze.
As you step inside, the aroma of freshly baked pizza wafts through the air, inviting you to indulge in a slice (or two). Reviewers consistently rave about the traditional flavors that exemplify what New York pizza should be. One customer noted, “Gaby's genuinely makes good quality pizza—fresh, piping hot, and cooked well.” This sentiment resonates with many who appreciate the balance of a doughy crust topped with their signature tomato sauce, which some describe as pleasantly sweet.
Cuisine lovers find themselves drawn to the moderate noise level and nostalgic ambiance, adorned with old-school photographs that tell the story of Gaby's rich heritage. It's a perfect backdrop for family gatherings or catching up with friends over happy hour specials. With the ability to accommodate groups and its good vibes, you’d feel right at home.
The menu is not exhaustive, but it serves some amazing highlights. From their classic pepperoni slices to a delectable Sicilian pie, each pizza promises quality with fresh ingredients and courteous service. One frequent visitor shared, “Gaby's sauce, dough, and cheese are on point.” It’s clear that the formula for success lies in their dedication to craft.
So, whether you’re looking for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner with your loved ones, Gaby’s Pizza is ready to serve you a slice of happiness. Don’t forget to try their happy hour deals and perhaps add a few pepper flakes to balance the sweetness of the sauce, just like the locals do. Trust us; your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I don't understand the backlash ... maybe bc I never tried gaby's during their "prime" back in the day. I was more of a margheritas girl. Not to bring up their other competition. I came across this gem rather late. But I feel like gabys genuinely makes good quality pizza. My pie was fresh piping hot & cooked well & tasted like good ol' classic NY pizza. The only thing I will say in which most ppl agree with is that their tomato sauce def has a sweetness to it. But I don't mind it. I love to pour a bunch of pepper flakes on my pizza so it balances it out. So they're still good in my book ”
“ Been coming here since I was a kid and it's still top 3 in NYC. Sauce is just right and more important- the crust, doughy and just the right amount of sauce. Fast service. Ambiance is average, but love the old school pictures. ”
“ To me Gabys is still one of the best slices in Queens. The staff is always courteous. Order 2 slices (one pepperoni) a Sicilian and 2 medium drinks for $17. The slice were fresh and cheesy with the perfect sauce/texture. ”
“ Can't wait...,. ..... u have to try this spot! Anyone who knows and love great New York slices give them a try today! Great family vibes and amazing service. ”
“ As a native and life long New Yorker, I've had many pizzas. Gaby's sauce, dough and cheese are on point. Excellent slice of pizza! ”
“ Came here after my Son-in-law Aunt (who lives around the corner) highly recommended this place. Sauce was good, crust was tasty and the cheese was delicious! Clean restaurant and have your mind made up before getting in line this place get's busy and people have places to go! LOL can you tell I wasn't prepared tehehehe BTW we reheated the pizza later that evening and it was still great - oven reheated. Anyhoo the grandbabies had the rainbow Italian Ice and they LOVED it. Next time we come to see Auntie we'll probably stop in again. Respectfully Reviewed. ”
“ I've been here before in my younger years (I'm still young ). I remember how someone loved their pizza so much. It's still pretty good. The place is very clean, spacious, and welcoming. I ordered 2 plain slices and 2 Sicilians. They also serve other Italian dishes such as pasta, which I'm eager to try. I'm giving it 4 stars for taste though...because for me I tasted more sauce than cheese. I have a particular taste for cheese and pizza in general that I've been missing. However their service was amazing, kind people and efficient. I see this place gets crowded quickly and often. It looks so different inside compared to outside. ”
“ I come here frequently. Always pleasant and quick service. Their pizza is consistent. They even has the restaurant decorated for Valentines Day! ”
